Skip to main content

Table 3 Evaluation of skin condition by trained observer

From: Evaluating the tolerability and acceptability of an alcohol-based hand rub – real-life experience with the WHO protocol

Item

Skin condition (score)

Visit 1 (day 0)

Visit 2 (day 3–5)

Visit 3 (day 28)

Redness

N

46

46

45

 

No redness (0)

11 (24%)

16 (35%)

19 (42%)

 

Slight redness or blotchy (1)

28 (61%)

25 (54%)

22 (49%)

 

Moderate redness (2)

7 (15%)

4 (9%)

4 (9%)

 

Strong redness (3)

0

0

0

 

Fiery red with oedema (4)

0

1 (2)

0

 

Proportion with score < 2*

84.7%

89.1%

91.1%

Scaliness

N

46

46

45

 

No scales (0)

29 (63%)

28 (61%)

33 (73%)

 

Very slight sporadic scales (1)

13 (28%)

16 (35%)

11 (24%)

 

Moderate scales (2)

4 (9%)

2 (4%)

1 (2%)

 

Considerable scales (3)

0

0

0

 

Proportion with score < 2*

91.3%

95.6%

97.7%

Fissures

N

46

46

44

 

No fissures (0)

30 (65%)

34 (74%)

37 (84%)

 

Very fine fissures (1)

14 (30%)

12 (26%)

5 (11%)

 

Broad, sporadic or several fissures (2)

2 (4%)

0

2 (5%)

 

Widespread cracks with haemorrhage or exudate (3)

0

0

0

 

Proportion with score < 2*

95.7%

100%

95.7%

Global score

N

45

46

44

 

No dry skin or irritations (0)

4 (9%)

8 (17%)

17 (39%)

 

Incidental dry skin (1)

25 (56%)

28 (61%)

23 (52%)

 

Dry skin and/or redness (2)

13 (29%)

10 (22%)

3 (7%)

 

Very dry, whitish rough skin (3)

2 (4%)

0

1 (2%)

 

Chappy skin without haemorrhage or exudate (4)

1 (2%)

0

0

 

Widespread fissures with haemorrhage or exudate (5)

0

0

0

 

Proportion with score < 2*

64.4%

77.8%

90.9%

  1. *WHO benchmark ≥ 75%.