Skip to main content

Table 2 Result of the consensus procedure

From: Development of key quality indicators for appropriate antibiotic use in the Republic of Korea: results of a modified Delphi survey

Quality indicator First questionnaire Application Consensus meeting Second questionnaire
Median % in highest quartile Conclusion Admitted Outpatient Surgical prophylaxis Agreement (%) Total score Conclusion
1 7 75 Accepted Yes Yes Yes Rephrased 100 114 Accepted
2 6 75 Accepted Yes No No Rephrased 100 100 Accepted
3 7 87.5 Accepted Yes No No Rephrased 100 103 Accepted
4 6 54.5 Discussed Yes No No Rephrased, accepted 91 89 Accepted
5 6 62.5 Discussed Yes No No Rephrased, accepted 87 82 Accepted
6 7 83.3 Accepted Yes Yes No   NA 109 Accepted
7 7 79.2 Accepted Yes Yes No   NA 96 Accepted
8 6 62.5 Discussed Yes No No Accepted 70 52 Accepted
9 6 70.8 Accepted Yes Yes No   91 88 Accepted
10 7 95.8 Accepted No No Yes Merge into QI 1 NA 113  
11 7 91.7 Accepted No No Yes   NA 109 Accepted
12 6.5 79.2 Accepted No No Yes   NA 103 Accepted
13 6 62.5 Discussed Yes No No Rejected NA NA Rejected
14 7 87.5 Accepted Yes Yes No   87 87 Accepted
15 6 58.3 Discussed Yes Yes No Rejected NA NA Rejected
16 4 12.5 Rejected No No No   NA NA Rejected
17 6 87.5 Accepted Yes Yes Yes   NA 92 Accepted
18 6.5 75 Accepted Yes Yes No Rephrased 91 84 Accepted
19 5 41.7 Rejected No No No   NA NA Rejected
20 6 75 Accepted Yes No No Rephrased 78 69 Accepted
21 5 41.7 Rejected Yes No No   NA NA Rejected
22 5 41.7 Rejected Yes No No   NA NA Rejected
23 6 58.3 Discussed No No No Rejected NA NA Rejected
24    Added No No No Accepted 74 58 Accepted
25    Added No No Yes Merge into QI 1 NA NA  
26    Added Yes Yes No Merge into QI 2 NA NA  
  1. NA not applicable, Q quality indicator