Skip to main content

Table 2 Result of the consensus procedure

From: Development of key quality indicators for appropriate antibiotic use in the Republic of Korea: results of a modified Delphi survey

Quality indicator

First questionnaire

Application

Consensus meeting

Second questionnaire

Median

% in highest quartile

Conclusion

Admitted

Outpatient

Surgical prophylaxis

Agreement (%)

Total score

Conclusion

1

7

75

Accepted

Yes

Yes

Yes

Rephrased

100

114

Accepted

2

6

75

Accepted

Yes

No

No

Rephrased

100

100

Accepted

3

7

87.5

Accepted

Yes

No

No

Rephrased

100

103

Accepted

4

6

54.5

Discussed

Yes

No

No

Rephrased, accepted

91

89

Accepted

5

6

62.5

Discussed

Yes

No

No

Rephrased, accepted

87

82

Accepted

6

7

83.3

Accepted

Yes

Yes

No

 

NA

109

Accepted

7

7

79.2

Accepted

Yes

Yes

No

 

NA

96

Accepted

8

6

62.5

Discussed

Yes

No

No

Accepted

70

52

Accepted

9

6

70.8

Accepted

Yes

Yes

No

 

91

88

Accepted

10

7

95.8

Accepted

No

No

Yes

Merge into QI 1

NA

113

 

11

7

91.7

Accepted

No

No

Yes

 

NA

109

Accepted

12

6.5

79.2

Accepted

No

No

Yes

 

NA

103

Accepted

13

6

62.5

Discussed

Yes

No

No

Rejected

NA

NA

Rejected

14

7

87.5

Accepted

Yes

Yes

No

 

87

87

Accepted

15

6

58.3

Discussed

Yes

Yes

No

Rejected

NA

NA

Rejected

16

4

12.5

Rejected

No

No

No

 

NA

NA

Rejected

17

6

87.5

Accepted

Yes

Yes

Yes

 

NA

92

Accepted

18

6.5

75

Accepted

Yes

Yes

No

Rephrased

91

84

Accepted

19

5

41.7

Rejected

No

No

No

 

NA

NA

Rejected

20

6

75

Accepted

Yes

No

No

Rephrased

78

69

Accepted

21

5

41.7

Rejected

Yes

No

No

 

NA

NA

Rejected

22

5

41.7

Rejected

Yes

No

No

 

NA

NA

Rejected

23

6

58.3

Discussed

No

No

No

Rejected

NA

NA

Rejected

24

  

Added

No

No

No

Accepted

74

58

Accepted

25

  

Added

No

No

Yes

Merge into QI 1

NA

NA

 

26

  

Added

Yes

Yes

No

Merge into QI 2

NA

NA

 
  1. NA not applicable, Q quality indicator