Trends in prevalence of extended-spectrum beta-lactamase-producing Escherichia coli isolated from patients with community- and healthcare-associated bacteriuria: results from 2014 to 2020 in an urban safety-net healthcare system

Background The prevalence of infections caused by extended-spectrum beta-lactamase producing Escherichia coli (ESBL-E. coli) is increasing worldwide, but the setting in which this increase is occurring is not well defined. We compared trends and risk factors for ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria in community vs healthcare settings. Methods We collected electronic health record data on all patients with E. coli isolated from urine cultures in a safety-net public healthcare system from January 2014 to March 2020. All analyses were stratified by healthcare-onset/associated (bacteriuria diagnosed > 48 h after hospital admission or in an individual hospitalized in the past 90 days or in a skilled nursing facility resident, N = 1277) or community-onset bacteriuria (bacteriuria diagnosed < 48 h after hospital admission or in an individual seen in outpatient clinical settings without a hospitalization in the past 90 days, N = 7751). We estimated marginal trends from logistic regressions to evaluate annual change in prevalence of ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria among all bacteriuria. We evaluated risk factors using logistic regression models. Results ESBL-E. coli prevalence increased in both community-onset (0.91% per year, 95% CI 0.56%, 1.26%) and healthcare-onset/associated (2.31% per year, CI 1.01%, 3.62%) bacteriuria. In multivariate analyses, age > 65 (RR 1.88, CI 1.17, 3.05), male gender (RR 2.12, CI 1.65, 2.73), and Latinx race/ethnicity (RR 1.52, CI 0.99, 2.33) were associated with community-onset ESBL-E. coli. Only male gender (RR 1.53, CI 1.03, 2.26) was associated with healthcare-onset/associated ESBL-E. coli. Conclusions ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria frequency increased at a faster rate in healthcare-associated settings than in the community between 2014 and 2020. Male gender was associated with ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria in both settings, but additional risks—age > 65 and Latinx race/ethnicity—were observed only in the community. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13756-021-00983-y.

Recent hospitalization and prior antibiotic use are major drivers of ESBL-E. coli infections, but factors unrelated to healthcare are increasingly recognized, including international travel and consumption of meat contaminated with ESBL-E. coli. [9][10][11][12][13][14] However, most studies compare infection with ESBL-E. coli to infection with drug-susceptible E. coli to assess risk for ESBL-E. coli infections [11]. As such, identified risks may determine infection with antimicrobial resistant E. coli and not necessarily ESBL-E. coli. Furthermore, despite the increasing prevalence of community-onset ESBL-E. coli infections, little is known about risk factors for such infections in community settings.
Previously, we found increasing trends in ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria in the San Francisco safety-net public healthcare system from 2012 to 2018, but community-onset cases could not be differentiated from those associated with healthcare exposure [15]. Here, we compared community-onset vs healthcare-onset/ associated bacteriuria episodes caused by ESBL-E. coli in the same public healthcare system from 2014 to 2020. This healthcare system serves a multiethnic, low-income, under-studied population residing in various neighborhoods. Identifying risk factors specific to community-onset bacteriuria caused by ESBL-E. coli in this population is paramount to devising effective antibiotic stewardship efforts and targeted interventions to reduce transmission within communities.

Study design and settings
This is an observational study drawn from electronic medical record (eMR) data at the San Francisco public healthcare system for all patients whose urine culture grew E. coli from January 2014 to March 2020. This healthcare system includes 15 primary care outpatient clinics as part of the San Francisco Health Network (SFHN), the San Francisco General Hospital (SFGH), an acute care hospital, and Laguna Honda Hospital (LHH), a skilled nursing facility. SFHN patients and LHH residents are usually hospitalized at SFGH. The SFGH microbiology laboratory processes all laboratory tests for this public healthcare system. Data on all urine cultures were collected, including bacterial species and antimicrobial susceptibility test results. We analyzed bacteriuria episodes, which may represent either urinary tract infection or asymptomatic bacteriuria, caused by E. coli. Bacteriuria episodes were defined as a single urine culture growing E. coli. If multiple cultures were sent on the same day, only one culture was considered. E. coli-positive urine cultures from separate days were considered to be separate episodes, as we could not differentiate between an untreated and a repeat urinary tract infection.

Exposure and outcome measures
To evaluate prevalence trends, we defined culture date as years since baseline (January 2014). Our primary independent variables were extracted from eMRs: age at time of culture (0-17, 18-34, 35-64, or over 65 years); gender (male or female); race/ethnicity (Asian, Black, Latinx, White, or Other); and preferred language (any Chinese dialect, English, Spanish, or Other).
Healthcare-onset/associated bacteriuria episodes were defined as cases in which a urine culture, obtained from a) inpatients after at least 48 h of hospital admission, b) outpatients who had been hospitalized in the 90 days prior to culture, or c) residents of the skilled nursing facility, grew E. coli. Community-onset E. coli bacteriuria episodes were defined as cases in which a urine culture, obtained in a) an outpatient clinic or emergency department setting, or b) within 48 h of inpatient admission, grew E. coli. These simplified definitions for healthcare onset/associated and community-onset were created due to the small sample size of community-onset healthcare-associated bacteriuria episodes. We sought to identify factors associated with Keywords: Extended-spectrum beta-lactamase, Escherichia coli, Antimicrobial resistance, Bacteriuria, Risk factors antimicrobial resistance in community-onset bacteriuria other than prior hospitalization, which is an already well-studied risk factor for antimicrobial resistance. Here, we assumed that individuals who had been hospitalized in the 90 days prior to urine culture would have similar healthcare exposures to those individuals whose urine cultures were obtained after 48 h of hospitalization.

Antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST)
The microbiology laboratory performs AST with Microscan and disk diffusion tests, with reports of resistance based on CLSI breakpoint standards [16]. The microbiology laboratory reports extended-spectrum betalactamase producing E. coli (ESBL-E. coli) as an E. coli strain resistant to ceftazidime or cefotaxime and inhibited by clavulanic acid using broth microdilution, per 2016 CLSI guidelines [16]. Results reported as "intermediate resistance" were considered resistant in this study ("Appendix").
Bacteriuria episode caused by ESBL-E. coli was the main outcome of interest. Sub-analyses included E. coli with resistance to nitrofurantoin, trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, ciprofloxacin (most commonly used to treat urinary tract infections), any resistance (defined as resistance to any antibiotic class based on all antibiotics tested routinely in the microbiology laboratory, see "Appendix" for a complete list), and multidrug resistance (defined as resistance to 3 or more classes of antibiotics). Sub-analyses initially included resistance to aminoglycosides and carbapenems; Additional file 1: Table S7 reports percentage resistance per year for each bacteriuria type and place of care.

Statistical data analysis
Descriptive statistics, including frequencies and percentages for categorical data and mean values with standard deviations for continuous data, were used to summarize key exposure and outcome variables. Differences in overall frequency of ESBL-E. coli and patient characteristics for community-onset versus healthcareonset/associated bacteriuria were evaluated with chisquared tests and t-tests. Annual changes in resistance to antimicrobial agents from 2014 to 2020 were fit with logistic regression models and trends were estimated based on marginal effects, separately for communityonset and for healthcare-onset/associated bacteriuria. To assess changes in the overall patient population, annual change in racial/ethnic distribution of patients with E. coli bacteriuria were also fit with logistic regression models and trends were estimated based on marginal effects. Unadjusted and covariate adjusted logistic regression models were performed separately for community-onset bacteriuria and healthcare-onset/ associated bacteriuria to assess which demographic characteristics of patients with bacteriuria predicted E. coli resistant to antimicrobial agents (considering as separate outcomes: ESBL-E. coli; resistance to each of 3 antibiotics separately [nitrofurantoin, trimethoprimsulfamethoxazole, and ciprofloxacin]; any drug resistance; and multidrug resistance). Bootstrap (clustered at the individual level) confidence intervals were reported for adjusted logistic regressions to adjust for repeated measures on unique patients [17]. All analyses were conducted by RStudio4 version 1.3.1073. We report 95% confidence intervals to characterize uncertainty in our effect estimates. Sub-analyses were also performed separately for place of care: outpatient, inpatient, and skilled nursing facility.

Characteristics of the study samples and patients
From January 2014 to March 2020, 82,800 urine samples were processed at the SFGH clinical microbiology laboratory. Of these, 13,522 urine cultures grew an identifiable organism, of which 9028 (67%) grew E. coli (7751 community-onset and 1277 healthcare-onset/associated). Of the 9028 urine cultures, 224 (2%) were obtained from catheterizations and 8804 (98%) from clean catch urine collections.
We identified 6291 unique patients with an E. coli bacteriuria episode. There were 5576 patients who met the definition of a community-onset E. coli bacteriuria. In addition, 926 patients had a healthcare-onset/associated bacteriuria; given that a patient may have had multiple bacteriuria episodes, these were not mutually exclusive (Table 1). There were 4844 outpatients, 1183 inpatients, and 264 skilled nursing facility residents. Fifteen hundred patients had more than one E. coli bacteriuria episode; one patient had as many as 27 episodes. Patients with community-onset bacteriuria (mean age 46) were younger compared to patients with healthcare-onset/ associated bacteriuria (mean age 60). Patients with bacteriuria were predominantly women (85%). The study population was multiethnic, with 40% Latinx, 20% Asian, 18% White, and 14% Black patients. Demographic characteristics of outpatients, inpatients and skilled nursing facility residents can be found in Supplemental Table 1. We conducted analyses to assess change in percent race/ethnicity distribution in patients with E. coli bacteriuria from 2014 to 2020. We found that percent annual change in Latinx patients with E. coli bacteriuria increased by 1.44% (95% CI 0.78, 2.10), whereas percent change in Black patients (− 0.5%; 95% CI − 0.99, − 0.04) and patients identified as other (− 0.76%; 95% CI − 1.12, − 0.41) decreased annually. Annual percent change in other race/ethnic groups were not significant (data not shown). Table 2 shows the overall frequency at which the E. coli bacteriuria episodes were resistant to antimicrobial agents. ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria frequency was higher in healthcare onset/associated bacteriuria episodes (24%) compared to those of community-onset bacteriuria (8%) (P < 0.001) (Tables 2 and 3). ESBL-E. coli accounted for only 13% of community-onset but 34% of healthcare onset/associated antimicrobial resistant E. coli bacteriuria episodes (P < 0.001). Bacteriuria episodes caused by ESBL-E. coli had 4.14 (95% confidence interval [CI] 3.41, 5.02) times the risk of nitrofurantoin resistance, 3.89 (95% CI 3.41, 4.43) times the risk of trimethoprimsulfamethoxazole resistance, and 12.95 (95% CI 11.15, 15.05) times the risk of ciprofloxacin resistance compared to bacteriuria caused by non-ESBL-E. coli. Amongst 14 carbapenem-resistant E. coli bacteriuria episodes, 6 were identified as community-onset, of which 2 were caused by non-ESBL-E. coli. All eight carbapenem-resistant E. coli strains causing healthcare onset/associated bacteriuria were ESBL-E. coli. The majority of ESBL-E. coli isolates were multidrug resistant (72% of 931) but only a minority (39% of 1707 isolates) of multidrug resistant episodes were due to ESBL-E. coli.

Association between patient demographic characteristics and ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria episodes by place of care
In multivariate regression models adjusted for age category, gender, race/ethnicity, preferred language, and hospitalization in the 90 days prior to urine culture, among all E. coli bacteriuria episodes from inpatients, male gender (RR 1.66, CI 1. 13   Results of associations between patient demographic characteristics and other antimicrobial agents are described in Additional file 1: Tables S5 and S6.

Discussion
In this study of drug-resistant E. coli bacteriuria spanning more than 6 years in a safety-net public healthcare system serving a diverse population, we found antimicrobial resistant E. coli frequency to increase over time in both community and healthcare settings. The magnitude of the increase was greatest among ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria, which doubled in community settings and increased by more than 40% in healthcare settings. Older age, male sex, and Chinese dialect or Spanish as a preferred language (or, in some models, Latinx race/ethnicity) were associated with higher prevalence of ESBL-E. coli among all E. coli bacteriuria episodes.
Increasing prevalence of ESBL-E. coli in communityonset and healthcare onset/associated infections is now observed worldwide [4,10,12,[18][19][20][21][22]. A 2019 CDC report showed a 50% increase in hospital-and community-onset infections caused by ESBL-producing Enterobacteriaceae between 2012 and 2017 in the US [2]. A report from the Study for Monitoring Antimicrobial Resistance Trends (SMART) found prevalence of urinary tract infections caused by ESBL-E. coli to increase from 7.8 to 18.3% between 2010 and 2014 in the US, particularly among hospital-associated infections [23]. In contrast, the authors found increasing prevalence in community-onset infections in Canada [23].
Most recently, a report on urinary tract infections in US hospitalized patients found a prevalence of 17.2% for ESBL-producing Enterobacteriaceae [24]. We have previously shown increase in ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria cases in the same San Francisco public healthcare system, but were unable to decipher whether this increase occurred in community or healthcare settings [15]. Here, while prevalence and increase per year was greater in healthcare onset/associated ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria, especially in skilled nursing facility residents as shown in separate analyses, we also found a significant increase among community-onset bacteriuria.
We first compared ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria to bacteriuria caused by all other E. coli strains (non-ESBL drug-resistant and drug-susceptible E. coli), which would not necessarily distinguish risk factors associated with ESBL-E. coli from those associated with drug-resistant E. coli. Therefore, we performed secondary analyses comparing ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria to bacteriuria caused by non-ESBL drug-resistant E. coli. For community-onset ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria, we found older age and male gender to be associated risk factors. For healthcareonset/associated bacteriuria, we found male gender to be associated with ESBL-E. coli.
The association with older age and male gender may represent complicated urinary tract infections more likely to occur in these populations, which may include catheter-associated infections or prostatitis requiring prolonged treatment with extended-spectrum betalactam drugs [25]. Since multidrug resistance is associated with ESBL-E. coli, factors contributing to frequent antibiotic exposures among older persons in community settings, such as frequent contact with healthcare, higher likelihood of recurrent urinary tract infection, and urinary retention requiring catheterization, may also contribute to the ESBL-E. coli selection [9,11,[26][27][28]. Few studies have found differences in ESBL-E. coli infection by race/ethnicity, independent of healthcare exposures. A New York study found that children identified as Asian had greater odds of infection with ESBL-producing Enterobacteriaceae [13]. Studies utilizing genotyping methods have found that the majority of community-onset urinary tract infection caused by ESBL-E. coli are caused by major pandemic E. coli lineages belonging to specific sequence types, including ST131 and ST69 [9,10,29]. This may point to commonsource exposures in the community. There is mounting evidence that infection with ESBL-E. coli is associated with international travel, particularly to South Asian countries, and food habits, including eating meat contaminated with ESBL-E. coli [11][12][13][14].
No study to our knowledge has found higher risk of ESBL-E. coli in Latinx populations. Our findings may represent increased access to antibiotics by this population in San Francisco, but prior studies from other regions in the US found no difference in access to and use of non-prescribed antibiotics among Latinx compared to non-Latinx individuals [30]. A majority of Latinx patients in this public healthcare system come from Mexico. Travel to Mexico may be a risk factor in our study population. A report from the SMART study showed that Mexico has the highest prevalence of community infections caused by ESBL-E. coli in Latin America [31]. Thus, unmeasured risk factors, such as travel and food consumption, may also be driving increasing community-onset bacteriuria caused by ESBL-E. coli. Additionally, we found that representation of Latinx patients in those with E. coli bacteriuria increased annually. While Covered California was founded in 2012, Healthy San Francisco, a program designed to provide healthcare services for uninsured San Francisco residents which works directly with our healthcare system, started in 2007. It is less likely that the increase in Latinx patients with E. coli bacteriuria is due to increased healthcare coverage, but perhaps to a change in use of healthcare services. The temporal increase and association of ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria among Latinx patients we observed in this study may have been driven by the temporal increase in this population group at risk.
While co-resistance of ESBL-E. coli to other antimicrobial agents, specifically fluoroquinolones and trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, is very common [3,9,[32][33][34], even more concerning is our finding of phenotypic carbapenem co-resistance amongst ESBL-E. coli. We found that 12 (86%) of 14 carbapenemresistant E. coli were ESBL-E. coli, although we do not have genetic information to evaluate whether they were carbapenemase-producers. A new report from the CRACKLE2 study found that 20% of non-carbapenemase-producing carbapenem-resistant Enterobacteriales isolated from hospitalized patients produced CTX-M, a common ESBL type [35]. Additionally, prior studies have found ESBL-E. coli co-resistance to nitrofurantoin to be either absent or negligible [36,37]. Our finding that ESBL-E. coli co-resistance to nitrofurantoin was higher than that of co-resistance to trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole may be representative of local antimicrobial resistance patterns, possibly driven by predominant E. coli sequence types.
There are several limitations to our study. First, community-onset cases were defined as cases with no history of hospitalizations in the 90 days at SFGH or LHH prior to urine culture. We did not obtain patient information before 90 days, when such patients could have had other healthcare exposures. Second, it may be that we underestimated hospitalization in the 90 days prior to urine culture if individuals were hospitalized in other healthcare systems. Prior studies, however, have shown high retention rate of patients within our public healthcare system [38]. Third, we combined community-onset healthcare-associated bacteriuria episodes with healthcare-onset ones. This is a simplified definition of healthcare-associated infections. Fourth, this is a retrospective study based on electronic health records, and thus we were not able to conduct molecular characterization of E. coli isolates. Lastly, while our study population is diverse in its racial/ethnic representation and their San Francisco neighborhoods, it is homogenous in that individuals receiving care in this public healthcare system have similar socio-economic circumstances. Thus, findings from our study may not be generalizable to other populations.

Conclusion
Our findings raise concerning trends in both community and healthcare settings of ESBL-E. coli bacteriuria among patients examined at a San Francisco safetynet public health system. As bacteriuria, in particular urinary tract infections, often precede complications such as bacteremia and sepsis, this observation has serious implications for the clinical management of many types of infections. These findings also have important public health implications, emphasizing an increasing need for better surveillance and antibiotic stewardship programs for community-onset infections.